Former Bitcoin-friendly U.S. regulator believes XRP is a currency; could American Express end up using it? ๐จ This article is 4 years old...
Former Bitcoin-friendly U.S. regulator believes XRP is a currency; could American Express end up using it?
3 min read
Updated: Jun. 18, 2020 at 9:42 am UTC
Image by 272447 from Pixabay
Chris Giancarlo, the ex-chairman of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and now independent law practitioner, released an extensive legal study on Wednesday concluding XRP is not a security asset and canโt be treated as such.
The self-styled โCrypto Dadโ was instrumental in spearheading studies at U.S. bourses and regulators that eventually led to Bitcoin and Ether being classified as commodities, similar to rice or sugar futures.
XRP an in-demand currency
Giancarloโs Howey Test analysis and application to XRP conclude the latter is more similar to the U.S. dollar than a security. However, it must be noted his law firm now works for Ripple โ which could mean partiality to the project.
A detailed argument published on the International Financial Law Review explored reasons why XRP, made by the team behind OpenCoin in 2012 and rebranded from โripplesโ in 2015, was not a security.
Cryptocurrencies and US securities laws: beyond bitcoin and ether https://t.co/IS6S5yvQXA via @intltaxreview
— Chris Giancarlo (@giancarloMKTS) June 17, 2020
Titled, โCryptocurrencies and U.S. Securities Laws: Beyond Bitcoin and Ether,โ and co-authored by New York law firm Willkie Farr & Gallagher LLP, Giancarlo methodically applied the Howey Test criteria to XRP.
$5.9 billion worth of XRP is currently in circulation, as per on-chain analytics site Messari. Ripple Labs โ despite distancing itself from XRP in certain areas โ continues to partly fund itself by periodically selling a portion of its 55.6 billion XRP, as Forbes reports.
However, he argues that a fair application of the Howey test places XRP as a medium of exchange. The paper adds โincreased adoptionโ of XRP โ evidenced by booming on-demand liquidity corridors and adoption in African markets โ means the currency is significantly used as a form of payment by consumers and businesses in recent times.
The Howey test
The U.S. SEC has criterias for securities fulfilling the Howey test. The first states any โinvestment contract should be implied or explicitly stated between the issuer of the asset.โ
Howey testโs second criteria notes there must be no โcommon enterpriseโ between shareholders or a shareholder and the company. To this, Giancarlo notes XRPโs intended use is that of a liquidity tool, with its more general use to transfer value and its potential as a speculative asset.
However, to the above points. While XRP is used as a medium for exchange now, as Giancarlo notes, the fact remains that Ripple was rebranded from OpenCoin, with the original creators of XRP (formerly ripples) then creating a distance of the currency (XRP) from Ripple. In essence, the firm was benefited greatly by the initial issuance of ripples and was a โcommon enterpriseโ for a few years, if not now.
Meanwhile, the third prong of the Howey test said there should โno reasonable expectation of profit should be derived from the efforts of Ripple.โ
Giancarlo noted the above in regard:
โThough Ripple maintains a sizable stake of the XRP supply and certainly has a pecuniary interest in the value of its holdings, it is not enough to suggest that a mutual interest in the value of an asset gives rise to an expectation of profits as contemplated by Howey.โ
Open-ended
Giancarloโs arguments, and any community or media rebuttals, remain open-ended topics for now. The formerโs arguments do hold weight in current times, if the creation of XRP and the history of Ripple is not considered.
In fact, thereโs plenty of support for XRP as a currency. Coinbase โ known for its legal-first listing for assets and distance from unlicensed securities โ added XRP support in February 2018 after the companyโs internal audit deemed the contrary.
So what does Giancarloโs argument mean anyway? For one, enterprise Ripple clients like American Express, Santander, and SBI Holdings Japan, which donโt use XRP currently in favor of RippleNet, could technically onboard XRP for use if itโs considered a currency.
That could, in turn, mean Ripple is propelled to one of the decadeโs biggest and most valuable startups; spurring more adoption and widespread crypto use considering the benefits.
Mentioned in this article
Latest US Stories
Latest XRP Stories
You might also enjoy...
Latest Press Releases
In this article
Theย XRP Ledgerย is a decentralized cryptographic ledger powered by a network of peer-to-peer servers.
Ripple
Ripple is a US-based technology company which develops the Ripple payment protocol and exchange network using XRP, the digital asset native to the XRP Ledger.
Christopher โChrisโ Giancarlo was unanimously confirmed to serve as Chairman of the U.S.
