Samuel Wan · 18 hours ago · 2 min read
Morgan Creek Digital Assets issued a $1 million challenge that the fund’s cryptocurrency index would outperform the S&P 500 over the next decade. Founded by Anthony Pompliano and other crypto bulls, the challenge is the perfect opportunity for cryptocurrency doomsayers to “put their money where their mouth is.”
In a press release today, Morgan Creek Digital Assets publicized a bet that the Bitwise index fund of cryptocurrencies—including Bitcoin and altcoins—would outperform the S&P 500, a capitalization-weighted index of 500 of the largest U.S. publicly traded companies.
The bet is open to professional investors who either “believe cryptocurrencies are worthless,” or simply think that “public equities would be a better investment over the next decade.”
The bet is a direct challenge to many in the community who have predicted the Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are a Ponzi scheme, a scam, or “going to zero.”
For example, Bitcoin pessimist Nouriel Roubini:
Now Bitcoin is again below $8K. Down 60% from its December peak. You HODLers : feel free to jump over the cliff to your financial meltdown…
— Nouriel Roubini (@Nouriel) March 15, 2018
Or Agustin Carstens, general manager of the Bank for International Settlements, a bank for central banks, who called Bitcoin:
“…the combination of a bubble, a Ponzi scheme, and an environmental disaster,” according to CNBC.
Now the naysayers have an opportunity to speak with their wallets.
Details on the Fund
The fund would have exposure to 75 percent of the cryptocurrency market and would churn monthly—changing with each coin’s market capitalization—to represent the changing proportions of the market.
The fund mainly comprises Bitcoin and Ethereum, with smaller stakes in eight other altcoins. The exact percentages are detailed below:
For those interested in the convenience of a managed portfolio, the fund is also offered to U.S. accredited investors with a minimum investment of $50 thousand. Something to keep in mind: it is possible that this bet is a marketing stunt used to drum up interest for the firm’s crypto fund.
MDMA also included an in-depth methodology as to how and why they chose the selected cryptocurrencies. Some of the more interesting criteria are listed below:
- Fewer than 30% of its current issuance held by the protocol’s foundation or related operating business.
According to the MDMA, this is to prevent undue centralization that may “potentially threaten” the fundamental value of a decentralized network, ruling out coins such as Ripple (XRP), Stellar Lumens (XLM), and TRON (TRX). Although Stellar Lumens (XLM) does intend to give out 95 percent of its holdings, it has only given out a tiny fraction thus far.
- Trades on two or more exchanges, with no more than 90 percent of combined 30-day trailing trading volume conducted on any single exchange.
This requirement exists to ensure that there is sufficient liquidity for buying and selling, and to remove a point of failure should a major exchange fail.
- Allows for air-gapped cold storage, including offline wallet generation and offline transaction signing.
This rule allows for the secure storage of any assets, mitigating losses from potential hacks.
Background on the Buffet Bet
The challenge is structured as a ‘Buffet Bet’ 2.0, a nod to Warren Buffet’s bet of $1 million that S&P index funds would outperform a selection of actively managed hedge funds. Warren Buffet won the bet handily, with the S&P 500 returning 7.1 percent interest compounded annually, compared to 2.2 percent with the selection of hedge funds.
Since its inception, the S&P500 averaged returns of 10 percent annually from 1920 through 2016. If dividends from these stocks were reinvested, it would be substantially higher. Whether cryptocurrency can outperform the solid returns of the equities market is still uncertain.
Other than the challenge, the press release did not mention any other details surrounding the bet.
It looks like the bulls are willing to put their money where their mouths are, but as stated by the firm, “…are any crypto detractors willing to do the same?”
Get an edge on the cryptoasset market
Access more crypto insights and context in every article as a paid member of CryptoSlate Edge.
Join now for $19/month Explore all benefits