Bitmain’s Rumored F3 Miner Potentially Disruptive to Ethereum
Rumors have surfaced that Bitmain is developing a powerful ASIC that threatens to increase centralization on the Ethereum blockchain.
Memory bandwidth, the rate at which data is read or stored into a memory chip by acomputer’s processor, has limited ASIC development on the Ethereum blockchain.
Mining Ethereum was programmed to be memory bound by design. This design prevents the proliferation of ASICs, as seen on the Bitcoin network, and thereby increases the decentralization and security of the Ethereum network.
How Ethereum Achieves Memory Bounding
The Ethash algorithm relies on generating something called the DAG, otherwise known as the directed acyclic graph. Fetching the DAG from the computer’s memory is the primary limiter on how fast a computer chip can execute the Ethash algorithm.
The size of the DAG is based on the Ethereum’s current blockchain length and grows in size in proportion to the size of the blockchain. The DAG is regenerated every 30,000 blocks or approximately every five days at current block rates.
As of today, the DAG file is 2.4 GB in size.
An important thing to note is mining is limited by the DAG size. If a GPU’s memory is lesser than the size of the DAG file, then it becomes impossible to mine cryptocurrency with that GPU.
This limitation in memory size also limits the scope of mining ASIC designers. There are some technical limitations that make building memory into cryptocurrency ASICs difficult.
Market Environment Surrounding Bitmain
This limitation in the Ethash algorithm makes it difficult to build an ASIC that is more cost-effective than a GPU. The primary chip designers in the mining space, Nvidia and AMD have an advantage in that regard.
Both of these companies can leverage massive supply and logistic chains to reduce the cost of manufacturing chips.
Chip manufacturing is incredibly capital intensive. Fabrication houses, the places where microchips are built, cost billions of dollars to design and construct. Only a few fabrication houses can produce the newest chips.
All of these factors limit a new entrant to the market like Bitmain.
However, Bitmain has become extremely profitable in a short amount of time.
According to Bernstein Research, Bitmain made $3 to $4 billion in profit in 2017, more than Nvidia and AMD combined.
With that much cash available to the company it is possible that they could break into the chip design niche for the cryptocurrency.
How to Build an Ethereum ASIC
ASIC chips only make sense if:
- The dollars per GB of memory bandwidth is lower, and there is enough memory total to store the DAG file
dollars / (GB/sec) < GPUs
- The chips are more power efficient assuming they are as powerful as available GPUs
watts / (GB/sec) < GPUs
Has Bitmain successfully designed a chip that is cheaper or more power efficient than Nvidia or AMD’s GPUs?
The Rumored F3 Ethereum Miner
Recently the mining and Ethereum community on Reddit has been in an uproar over a rumored ASIC developed by the mining giant Bitmain.
According to the Chinese news website, Tech news, the F3 Ethereum miner is said to have 72 GBs of DDR3 memory and has been in production since February.
It is also said that Bitmain is establishing relationships with Taiwanese chip manufacturers to reduce the costs of these chips further.
According to China Tech News, the F3 is expected to launch in the Q2 or Q3 of 2018.
In an unverified post on Reddit, an image of an alleged F3 miner is seen in action. In the image, an F3 produces 1500 MH/s, the equivalent of 50 RX570 GPUs.
In response to the threat of the new ASIC, the Ethereum Improvement Proposal (EIP) repository has opened a thread with a referendum to hard fork the Ethereum blockchain and to make Ethereum more ASIC-resistant.
Members of the Ethereum community say a hard fork of the Ethereum blockchain would hinder Bitmain’s development of the F3.
One of Etheruem’s lead developers, Vlad Zamfir, issued a poll on Twitter asking the community whether they would support a hard fork of the Ethereum blockchain to delay ASIC development.
Would you support a hard fork that obsceletes ETH ASICs? (Just wondering, this is not a proposal)
— Vlad Zamfir (@VladZamfir) March 28, 2018
In the face of this recent threat, it appears that one thing that the community is in consensus about is hard forking the Ethereum blockchain. The move may also prove to be unnecessary considering that Ethereum plans to move to proof-of-stake, possibly by the end of 2018.
All of the competing stakeholders may make change difficult.