A metal shutter blocks a tBTC service window while orange cases marked with Bitcoin logos remain visible behind glass.
Image by CryptoSlate

Threshold’s 11-day Bitcoin redemption freeze exposes a hidden risk in BTC-backed tokens

The protocol held more Bitcoin than its outstanding tBTC supply, yet security patches and bridge failures temporarily blocked redemptions.

Quick Take

  1. Threshold restored tBTC redemptions on Nov. 10 after an 11-day freeze caused by technical and security issues.
  2. The bridge held 4,320 BTC against 4,185 tBTC in circulation, yet holders could not redeem their tokens during the suspension.
  3. Threshold found no unexplained Bitcoin outflows, but the incident exposed how bridge failures can disrupt access to fully backed assets.

Threshold Network suspended tBTC redemptions for 11 days despite holding more Bitcoin than tokens in circulation.

The protocol said in a Nov. 18 post-mortem that its app stopped accepting redemption requests on Oct. 30 after unexpected bridge activity raised security concerns. Redemptions resumed Nov. 10 following technical fixes.

The interruption prevented holders from converting tBTC, a Bitcoin-backed token used across decentralized finance (DeFi), into native Bitcoin through Threshold's app. Users could still transfer and trade their existing tokens, while lending platform Aave restricted activity in its tBTC market.

Related Reading

Bitcoin redemption freeze puts $136 million Aave market under scrutiny

However, the disruption did not appear to stem from insufficient Bitcoin reserves.

Threshold reported that its bridge wallets held 4,320.46 BTC against 4,185.155 tBTC in circulation on Oct. 31, leaving approximately 135 BTC more than the outstanding token supply.

What caused the tBTC redemption freeze?

Threshold attributed the interruption to separate technical and security issues that affected its ability to process Bitcoin transactions.

The team had identified a problem with how the bridge accounted for Bitcoin deposits before the suspension. Meanwhile, another security issue forced some node operators responsible for signing Bitcoin transactions to take their systems offline for patches.

Under Threshold's design, a bridge wallet requires signatures from more than half its designated signers to authorize a Bitcoin transaction. This meant withdrawals could not proceed until enough operators returned online.

The protocol also needed to restore Bitcoin transaction proof submissions, which allow the bridge to verify deposits and redemption payouts.

Threshold said it fixed the deposit-accounting issue and upgraded the bridge before its Council restored permission to submit Bitcoin proofs on Nov. 7.

The app subsequently reopened around 03:00 UTC on Nov. 10, allowing holders to initiate redemptions again.

How tBTC redemptions came back

Threshold reauthorized Bitcoin proof submission before it reopened the app to new redemption requests.

Proof submission was reauthorized on Nov. 7. New redemption requests through the app resumed on Nov. 10.

Threshold’s written account gives a signer threshold but does not separately date the return of a signing majority. The timeline represents calendar dates at day precision.

The team also reviewed 57 registered tBTC wallet addresses and the bridge contracts for activity between Oct. 25 and Nov. 12.

It matched 31 BTC redemption payouts to their corresponding bridge proofs and reported finding no unexplained Bitcoin outflows in the wallets examined.

Essentially, the findings indicate the interruption was an operational failure rather than a depletion of BTC reserves.

However, the incident exposed a broader vulnerability for Bitcoin-backed assets used in DeFi: even when reserves are sufficient, technical failures can temporarily prevent holders from accessing their underlying BTC.

Article context

Mentioned in this article

Related Asset Bitcoin #1 BTC $62,649.80 24-hour change: down 0.64% Loading price history… 24H Down 0.64% 7D Down 12.78% 30D Down 24.14% Related Asset tBTC TBTC $65,304.25 24-hour change: up 0.30%